Lies Debunked: Why is Scientology Opposed to Psychiatry?


Scientology's doublecross

Scientology's® Claims

Subject: Why is Scientology Opposed to Psychiatry?
Date: 2000/03/06

Why is Scientology opposed to psychiatry?

What the Church opposes are brutal, inhumane psychiatric treatments. It does so for three principal reasons: 1) procedures such as electro- shock, drugs and lobotomy injure, maim and destroy people in the guise of help; 2) psychiatry is not a science and has no proven methods to justify the billions of dollars of government funds that are poured into it; and 3) psychiatric theories that man is a mere animal have been used to rationalize, for example, the wholesale slaughter of human beings in World Wars I and II.

Scientologists abhor "treatments" which harm people and particularly dislike it when those responsible refuse to take responsibility for their acts or to institute reforms in their own field. Scientologists are instinctively opposed to those who abuse their power or who harm the innocent and weak. Scientologists particularly object to the materialistic view advanced by psychiatry that man is a soulless animal.

The words psychiatry and psychology both come from the Greek word "psyche," meaning "the soul." The word psychology originally meant "study of the soul." In 1879, however, German professor Wilhelm Wundt of Leipzig University advanced the idea that investigating the soul or spirit was fruitless, that man was simply another animal, and that he could be studied in the same manner as an animal.

Scientologists, on the other hand, hold that man is a spiritual being. Furthermore, by the Creed of the Church, the healing of mentally caused ills should not be condoned in non-religious fields.

Scientologists aim to create a world without war, without insanity and without criminality. Psychiatric practices, on the other hand, destroy minds and reduce man to a robotized and drugged state where he can be controlled. Despite psychiatryís vast absorption of government funds, crime, illiteracy and drug addiction -- social problems that would decline if psychiatry were doing its self-imposed job of handling the problems of the mind -- continue to proliferate.

Even when psychiatric treatments do not tear apart living tissue, psychiatrists routinely tell their patients what they think is "wrong" with them, thus interjecting the psychiatrists' own prejudices, preferences and falsehoods into the therapy and so denying the patient a chance of recovery.

A true therapy would enable a person to find out for himself the source of his troubles and give him the ability to improve conditions in his own life, relationships and environment.

Violent psychiatric therapies create not only physical but spiritual traumas. At best, psychiatry suppresses life's problems; at worst it causes severe damage and irreversible setbacks in a personís life and even death.


And now for the truth

The reasons why the Scientology organization hates the mental health industry have been covered in some detail in Scientology's Mad Messiah Begs for Psychiatric Help, also within Lies Debunked: Citizens Commission on Human Rights, and in the web page called L. Ron Hubard's Rampat Drug Abuse Problems. Since it's covered elsewhere I won't bother addressing the usual outrageous claims that Scientologys spokesperson above made.

Instead I'll note that Scientology's pathologicall insane hatred of the mental health industry is unacceptably dangerous to people who are not followers or the criminal enterprise. Because Scientology's more unfortunate ringleaders actively work to stop people from getting the psychiatric help they need, Scientology's activities are deadly.

The Scientology organization tells its followers that the psychiatric industry is being controlled by the Marcabs from outer space to keep humanity enslaved and that Scientology is the only hope and salvation for humanity. Obviously such unfortunate notions are the result of the delusional insanity of Scientology's mad messiah L. Ron Hubbard and it wouldn't really matter to anyone outside of the Scientology organization if followers are told to believe such things. When the organization's ringleaders work hard to inflict their insanity upon the innocent populace, however, innocent people who swallow Scientology's insane claims and doesn't seek professional psychiatric assistance because of it often wind up killing themselves.

One of Hubbard's biggest problem was the fact that the mental health industry ignored him and his insane claims outright. Being ignored by an organization which Hubbard believe should have given him a Nobel Prize drove Hubbard to increasing levels of paranoid insanity. But because the criminal enterprise constitutes such a danger to people the mental health industry has from time to time been forced to note the quack claims of the criminal enterprise. Here's an example:

A Response to Scientology
By Abraham L. Halpern, M.D., and Alfred M. Freedman, M.D.
(Psychiatric News, December 6, 1996)

We read with great interest your article in the October 18 issue on the Church of Scientology's Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) titled "APA Helps Members Respond to Scientology's Attacks."

We would like to present some firsthand information concerning the destructive influence of the CCHR.

In 1986 the Special Rapporteur of the United Nations Subcommission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities submitted a report that was published and widely distributed by the United Nations. The report (known as the "Daes Report" but officially titled "Principles, Guidelines, and Guarantees for the Protection of Persons Detained on Grounds of Mental III Health or Suffering from Mental Disorder") was presented as "A contribution to: (a) the protection of the fundamental freedoms, human and legal rights of persons who are mentally ill or suffering from mental disorder; (b) the abolition of psychiatric abuses; (c) the promotion of mental health law and medical practice; and (d) the improvement of mental health care and mental institutions."

In fact, the report was an attack on psychiatry embodying all the distortions and outright lies invented and promulgated by the antipsychiatry movement over the years. The contribution of Scientology's CCHR, as one of the special organizations whose advice was sought by the Rapporteur, was prominently mentioned in the report. The United Nations document, quoting from the CCHR, included the following:

"All over the world, branches of CCHR offered help to members of parliaments to increase their awareness of mental health situations, so that actual reform could occur. CCHR made the following basic suggestions in connection with the subject under study:

"(a) Governments should start immediately to investigate psychiatry and the mental health field and get the real facts;

"(b) The CCHR and others should provide governments with workable methods to handle the mentally ill;

"(c) An amnesty should be granted to all psychiatrists who admit to having engaged in abusive practices and human rights violations and who have ceased to do so;

"(d) All community health centers and other mental care homes should be run by churches or other religious groups who have a real care for patients and a workable method;

"(e) The use of all drugs, whether street drugs or psychopharmacological drugs, should be discontinued.

"The conclusion of CCHR is, 'There will be peace on earth when the mental health field has been reformed and is clean'."

In a 1986 "report" submitted to the International Congress on Law and Psychiatry, the CCHR used scurrilous and inflammatory statements to denounce the professions of psychiatry and psychology including the following:

"It is no longer a case of 'the cure being worse than disease.' It is now a matter of the 'cure' causing the 'disease.' Psychiatry has long looked upon and dealt with nearly all behavior and manifestations of life from a purely biological, genetic, and medical viewpoint, i.e., 'man is an animal.' Perhaps it is now time to apply this medical viewpoint to the field of psychiatry and to eradicate this criminal 'cancer' that is consuming society.

"Most of the famous assassins and mass murderers are products of psychiatry and the mental health profession."

We were most dismayed at this brazen step to incorporate the malicious CCHR position in a United Nations document and began strenuous efforts to oppose it. In collaboration with colleagues at home and abroad, including an APA task force, we were able to mount a coordinated counterattack involving the World Psychiatric Association, the World Health Organization, and many others. As a result of our efforts, revised guidelines consistent with principles long accepted by American psychiatry were eventually approved by the U.N. General Assembly in a resolution adopted December 17, 1991.

In retrospect, instead of resting on our laurels, we should have called for eternal vigilance regarding CCHR activities and for rapid response by APA and other mental health organizations to the diabolical misrepresentations by CCHR. It is gratifying to see that APA, at the urging of the California Psychiatric Association, is undertaking a reasoned and responsible rebuttal.

We note that APA President Harold Eist, M.D., and Dorothy W. Cantor, Psy.D., president of the American Psychological Association, are working together to combat the policies and practices of the managed care industry that impede psychiatric and psychological treatment of mental illness. We urge Drs. Eist and Cantor to join forces to deal with the CCHR's anti-mental health depredations.

Amusingly, Scientology's head ringleader David Miscaviage claimed that Scientology was going to destroy and replace the mental health industry by the year 2000. Such delusional megalomania might be amusing yet when such individuals have some 40,000 followers world wide, they constitute a serious threat to people's health and safety.

Scientologists are told to believe they're infested with invisible murdered aliens from outer space they call "Body Thetans." The organization has the "cure," however: "Auditing," a quack medical fraud where subjects hold on to a device that's basically an Ohm meter and, as they're asked questions, these invisible space aliens which infest the subject are "blown."

Scientology's demand that "The CCHR and others should provide governments with workable methods to handle the mentally ill" is a demand that Scientology be allowed to scrape off people's "Body Thetan" infestation and that real psychiatric help be halted entirely is a notion which is at times both amusing and deadly.


The views and opinions stated within this web page are those of the author or authors which wrote them and may not reflect the views and opinions of the ISP or account user which hosts the web page. The opinions may or may not be those of the Chairman of The Skeptic Tank.

The name "Scientology"® is trademarked to the "Church" of Scientology. Neither this web page, nor this web site, nor any of the individuals mentioned herein assisting to educate the public about the Scientology organization's "Volunteer Minister" program are members of or representatives of the Scientology organization. Quotes used within this web page and within this web site are used according to the Fair Use laws of the United States.

If you find anything inaccurate or otherwise mistaken on this web page, please send a correction to COSVM at the e-mail address offered below -- with our thanks.

Back to the start of the Volunteer Minister web site

COSVM Web Site